| |
Research Article
|
|
The Effects of Different Harvesting Periods in Some Forage Crops Mixture on Herbage Yield and Quality
|
|
C. Balabanli
and
M. Turk
|
| |
ABSTRACT
|
|
This study was carried out between 2002-2004 in Suleyman
Demirel University Agricultural Faculty Experimental and Application Farm
in order to determine the effect of different Hungarian vetch-barley mixture
rates and harvesting periods. In the experiment, the effects of three
different harvesting periods (Pre-blooming, 50% blooming, fruit ripening)
and five different mixture rates (25% vetch+ 75% barley, 50% vetch +50%
barley, 75% vetch+ 25% barley only vetch and only barley) on plant length,
herbage yield, dry matter yield and crude protein yield were investigated.
At the end of the research it was found out that when the rate of barley
increased in the mixture plants became taller, herbage yield and dry matter
yield increased and crude protein yield decreased. The highest herbage
and dry matter yield were obtained between single barley and the mixture
of 25% vetch + 75% barley, pre-blooming and 50% blooming periods the highest
value of crude protein yield was obtained in the mixture of 75% vetch+
25% barley. Harvesting period didn`t effect the plant length and crude
protein yield. |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
INTRODUCTION
Human beings have been in the efforts of better
nutrition, lodging and dressing. In better nutrition, animal nourishment
plays the most significant role. On Earth, people are fed better where
cattle breeding is better. However, in under developed countries people
are not fed enough.
This problem can only be abolished by means of increasing
cattle breeding. In order to increase cattle breeding, genetic materials
having high yield capability, must be used and animals must be fed with
suitable food. A good and suitable nutrition is possible when animals
have enough carbohydrates, proteins, vitamins, minerals and other materials.
Leguminosae and cereal fodders, when they are used together
in animal nourishing, have great nutritive feature with the nutrition
materials they contain. Animals eat the leguminosae-cereal mixture with
a good appetite, because these mixtures are much more delicious than single
leguminosae and cereal. Leguminosae food plants provide high product increase
since they contain protein at high rate and vitamins and some mineral
materials in their structure (Serin et al., 1999; Avcioglu, 2000;
Açikgöz, 2001). Cereal food-plants, play a great role on cattle
feeding, the work of animals stomach and intestine systems, because they
contain carbohydrates at different rates in their structures.
In mixed sowing, rates of the vetch and grains and cropping
in a suitable period are the most important factors that affect the yield
and quality.
Herbage and dry grass yield increased with the cereals
increase in the mixture (Arslan and Gülcan, 1996). In some researches,
dry herbage grass and crude protein yields were obtained when leguminosae-cereal
rate was 50 +50 % in the mixture (Anlarsal and Yücel, 1994; Bayram
and Çelik, 1996; Basbag et al., 1999). In general, the higher
herbage, dry grass and dry matter yields were found vetch-barley mixture
in proportion with plain sowing (Orak, 1997).
In addition to the mixture rates, another factor effecting
the yield and nutrition values of fodder crop is harvesting period. While
Akyildiz (1986) and Ergül (1988) claim that dry matter and crude
cellulose rates increase, but crude protein rate decreases when the increased
of growth period for all plants (Akyildiz, 1986; Ergül, 1988). Ayhan
et al. (2004) claims that during the growth periods of leguminosae
fodder crops, herbage, dry grass and dry matter yields values obviously
increase (Ayhan et al., 2004).
This research has been carried out to determine the most
convenient mixture rate and harvesting period of Hungarian vetch which
can be grown in winter and barley according to yield and quality.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This research was carried out in the years of 2002
and 2004 at Suleyman Demirel University Agricultural Faculty Experimental
and Application Farm.
In both two years, the average heat and relative moisture
rates of the Experiment Area during the vegetation period were nearly
equal. However, the total rainfall in the second year (570.5 mm) was much
higher than the first year (543.1 mm) (Anonymous, 2004). For the research
Hungarian Vetch (Vicia pannonica Crantz.) and Barley (Hordeum
vulgare L.)are provided from Field Crops Central Research Institute;
In divided plots harvesting periods formed the main plots and mixture
rates formed the sub-plots. The experiment was replicated three times
according to the experiment pattern.
The harvesting periods were determined taking the physiologic
periods of the Hungarian vetch into consideration. The harvest was done
in pre-blooming, 50% blooming and fruit ripening periods. The mixture
rates were as follows: 75% Hungarian vetch + 25% Barley, 50% Hungarian
vetch + 50% Barley, 25% Hungarian Vetch + 75% Barley , 100% Vetch and
100% Barley. After sowing, 5 kg day-1 nitrogen and 5 kg day-1
phosphorus were applied the plots. In single sowing, 12 kg day-1
vetch and 25 kg day-1 barley were sowed and the mixtures were
prepared on these norms. The experiment plots were formed with 6 rows
(each row 5 m length) and sowing distance was 30 cm in the plots. The
plots were hoed in early spring. The edges of the plots (50 cm) were harvested
in each harvesting period and they were excluded in the study. Ten plants
were selected randomly for recording data on plant height. Herbage yield
was measured by reaping and weighing the parcels and converting the values
into kg day-1 in the period that sub-legumes of plants were
filled after throwing the side efficient. Dry matter proportion was found
following these steps; firstly 100 g herbage sample, taken from each parcel
randomly were dried in open air, then the samples were placed in an oven
at 105 °C until the weights were fixed and finally the samples were
weighed and compared to wet weights. Dry matter yield (kg day-1)
calculated by multiplying herbage yield and dry matter proportion in each
parcel and converting the results into kg day-1. The dried
plant material was ground for crude protein content using Kjeldahl method
(Kaçar, 1984). Crude protein values were obtained by multiplying
crude protein proportions by dry herbage values of parcels and by converting
these values into square kg day-1.
The data was evaluated in MSTAT-C statistic programme
and the LSD was used to determine the importance level of the difference
among the averages.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
It was found that the effects of the mixture rates
on the height of the vetch was significantly important in the averages
in two years. However harvesting periods didn`t have any significant effect
on the height of the vetch. Shortest plants were obtained from the plots
where single vetch was sowed in 2003-2004 and the highest plants were
found from the plots where 50% or less vetch were sowed. When averages
are compared in two years, the shortest plants (56 cm) were found from
single vetch sowing and the highest plants (62.3 cm) were obtained from
25% vetch + 75% barley mixture. The height of the plant in mixtures was
higher than the single vetch sowing could be caused by the competition
between vetch and barley and this position might have affected the height
of the plant positively (Table 1). Arslan and Gülcan
(1996) and Soya et al. (1996) also reported similar results in
their researches. Like vetch, barley mixture rates statistically played
important roles on plant height in two year average; however harvesting
periods didn`t cause important differences. Generally, when barley rate
increased in mixtures, plants heights also increased and reached its highest
values in single barley harvesting. Arslan and Gülcan (1996) also
notified similar results to our findings.
The mixture rates on herbage yield were found statistically
significant as shown in Table 1 in 2003 and 2004 and in two year averages.
The highest herbage yield were obtained from the plots where single barley
and 25% vetch 75% barley were sowed and the lowest herbage yields were
taken from the plots where single vetch was sowed. When the barley rate
in the mixture was increased the herbage yield was also increased (Table
1). Arslan and Gülcan (1996) also agree with these results. The
effect of harvesting period on herbage yield in 2004 and two year average
was found statistically important. The highest herbage yield in 2004 (2400.9
kg day-1) was obtained in pre-blooming period and the lowest
(2275.5 kg day-1) was found in fruit ripening period. According
to the two year average, the herbage yields determined from the harvesting
in pre-blooming and 50% blooming periods were high. Generally, it seems
that when harvesting period was late, herbage yield was lower (Table
1). The plants were in generative period and the sub-leaves ran dry
caused the herbage yields decrease when harvesting period was late.
The effect of the rates of different mixture on dry matter yield has
been found statistically important. The highest dry matter yield has been
obtained from the parcels which single barley has been sowed and the lowest
dry matter yield has been obtained from the parcels
| Table 1: |
The average values of plant height and herbage yield which has
been obtained from five different mixture and three different harvesting
time |
 |
| Table 2: |
The average values of dry matter yield and crude protein yield
which has been obtained from five different mixture and three different
harvesting time |
 |
where single vetch has been sowed. According to the average
within two years in proportion to the parcels where single vetch has been
sowed (338.6 kg day-1) 81.7% more dry matter yield has been
obtained in the parcels which single barley has been sowed (Table
2). The increase of the rate of barley in the mixture caused an increase
in the dry matter yield. This is because barley has developed more strongly
than vetch. The effect of the time of harvesting on dry matter yield hasn`t
been found statistically significant in 2003 but it has been found significant
in 2004 and the average within two years. In 2004, the highest dry matter
yield has been obtained from the parcels which has been harvested before
blooming (547.8 kg da-1) and the lowest dry matter yield has
been obtained from the parcels which has been harvested in fruit ripening
period. According to the average within two years before blooming and
in the 50% blooming period the crop is high whereas in fruit ripening
period the crop is low. Generally, it seems that if the harvesting has
been delayed the dry matter yield has decreased.
The effect of the rate of mixture on the crude protein
yield has been found statistically significant and the effect of the time
of harvesting on crude protein yield hasn`t so much importance in 2003
and 2004. The highest crude protein yield has been obtained from 50% vetch
+ 50% barley and 75% vetch + 25% barley mixture and the lowest crude protein
yield has been obtained from single barley parcels (Table
2). According to the results of the average within two years the highest
crude protein yield has been obtained with 77.27 kg day-1 and
with the mixture of 75% vetch + 25% barley. The lowest crude protein yield
has been obtained with 51.70 kg day-1 and by sowing single
barley. As the rate of vetch in the mixture has increased, the rate of
crude protein has also increased, so 75% vetch + 25% barley mixture has
the highest crude protein yield. Although the highest dry matter yield
has been obtained from single barley parcels, as the rate of crude protein
is low in barley, the lowest crude protein yield has been obtained from
the parcels which barley has been sowed.
As a result, the height of the plant single barley and
the mixture of barley at high rate has been found higher and the time
of harvesting hasn`t effected the height of the plant either in barley
or in vetch. The highest herbage and dry matter yield has been obtained
with the mixture of 25% vetch and 75% barley and between before blooming
and 50% blooming period. The highest value with regard of crude protein
yield has been obtained in the mixture of 75% vetch + 25% barley and it
has been concluded that the time of harvesting has no importance on crude
protein yield.
|
|
REFERENCES |
Acikgoz., E., 2001. Forage Crops. 3rd Edn., University of Uluda Publishing, Bursa.
Akyildiz, A.R., 1986. Technology and Acknowledgment of Fodder. University of Ankara Agricultural Faculty, Publishing No. 974, Ankara.
Anlarsal, A.E. and C. Yucel, 1994. Determining the most suitable seeding rates and cutting times of field pea-tritikale mixtures under lowland conditions. Agric. Mediterranean Int. J. Agric. Sci., 124: 207-212.
Anonymous, 2004. Isparta province data of meteorological district directorate. Isparta.
Arslan, A. and H. Gulcan, 1996. A research on the effects of cutting time to herbage yield and some agricultural characters on the mixtures of common vetch and barley grown as fallow crop under Southeastern Anatolia Region. Proceedings of the 3rd Turkey Grassland and Forage Congress, June 17-19, 1996, Erzurum, pp: 341-354.
Avciolu, R., 2000. The strategies of roughage production of animal husbandry in Turkey. Proceedings of the International Animal Nutrition Congress, Sept. 4-6, University of Süleyman Demirel, Agricultural Faculty, Isparta, pp: 448-455.
Ayhan, V., C. Balabanli, R. Avciolu and M. Ergül, 2004. The effect of harvest time on yield and nutrient contents of some legume forage crops. Proceedings of National Zootechnic Science Congress, Sept. 1-3, Isparta, pp: 166-172.
Baoba, M., I. Gül and V. Saruhan, 1999. The effect of different mixture rate on yield and yield components in some annual legumes cereals in Diyarbakir conditions. Proceedings of Turkey 3rd Field Crops Congress, Nov. 15-18, Turkey, pp: 69-74.
Bayram, G. and N. Çelik, 1996. Researches on the effect of mixture rates and the levels of nitrogen fertilizer in mixtures oat (Avena sativa L.) and vetch (Vicia sativa L.) on hay yield and quality. Proceedings of Turkey 3rd Field Crops Congress, Nov. 15-18, Turkey, pp: 53-58.
Ergul, M., 1988. Technology and Acknowledgment of Fodder. University of Ege, Agricultural Faculty, Publishing No. 487, Izmir.
Kacar, B., 1984. Plant Nutrition Practice Book. University of Ankara. Agricultural Faculty Publishing, Publish No. 900, Ankara.
Orak, A., 1997. The effect of different fertilizer levels on the yield and yield components of Hungarian vetch (Vicia pannonica Crantz.). Proceedings of Turkey 2nd Field Crops Congress, Sept. 22-25, Turkey, pp: 426-430.
Serin, Y., M. Tan and D. Öztürk, 1999. A study on fertilization of vetch and barley mixtures. Proceedings of Turkey 3rd Field Crops Congress, Nov. 15-18, Adana, pp: 47-52.
Soya, H., R. Avciolu and H. Geren, 1996. Effect of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) as nurse crop and rate of mixtures and row spacing on the seed yield and yield characteristics of common vetch. Proceedings of Pasture-Meadow, Forage Crops Congress, Jun. 17-19, Erzurum, pp: 328-333.
|
|
|
 |